False hit in Facial Recognition software led to the arrest of a Black man in Boston

Facial recognition tech is used in our day to day life to unlock smartphone or to tag friends on social media. Some airports use this to scan passengers before they board flight. Departments of motor vehicles use this tech to detect license fraud, identify theft.


Black lives matter
Image source - Google


Most common use of face recognition technology is law enforcement departments. After Williams case, many cities already banned using facial recognition technology.


Detroit police were trying to find out the guy whole stole watches from a Shinola retail store. The worth of the watches stolen are expected to be $3,800. The officers got access to the store security footage, zoomed into the grainy footage and squared out the picture of the suspect. Later, the picture of the suspect was run through the facial recognition software. The software came up with the person as Robert Julian-Borchak Williams, a 42-year-old from Farmington Hills, Mich., which is about 25 miles northwest of Detroit.


In January, Williams’ was arrested and taken into interrogation room. Police put three photos in front of him, out of which two photos were from the surveillance camera in the store and a photo from state-issued driver’s license. Williams denied saying that he is not the one from the surveillance footage but agreed that the person in the license is himself.


Williams was in remand for 30 hours and then release on a court bail until a court hearing on the case. At the hearing, court announced that the charges against Williams were dropped because of insufficient evidence. You can check the entire report here.


Michigan State Police - Investigative Lead Report
Image source - Google

Williams is the first person in the U.S. who got wrongfully arrested based on the false hit produced by facial recognition technology. 


The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Michigan filed a complaint against the Detroit Police Department asking the police stop using the software in investigations. After Williams case, the department passed a bill of new rules. Now, only still photos should be used for facial recognition not the surveillance footages. Only in the case of violent crimes, facial recognition should be used.


Many Academic and government studies have demonstrated that facial recognition systems misidentify color people more often than others. Most of the nation’s law enforcement agencies have access to face recognition tools and most of the time, people who are arrested using facial recognition are not told face recognition was used to arrest them.


Companies like Amazon, Microsoft and IBM have announced that they are not selling face recognition technologies to law enforcement agencies, however many other smaller, more specialized companies, like South Carolina based DataWorks Plus, the company which supplied the Detroit Police Department with its face-scanning software are still ready to make deals.


DataWorks Plus has supplied the technology to government agencies in Santa Barbara, California, Chicago and Philadelphia.


Williams case is a wake-up call to lawmakers to enact new rules into the law to avoid such cases in future.

BLACK LIVES MATTER

0 comments:

Post a Comment